There is an intense but civilized and scientific discussion on internet, among devoted, learned and intellectual members of Hindu community. While vast majority are against “Open Air Cremation” (OAC), mainly for practical reasons, there is tiny minority who support it on cultural, “Dharmic Faith” as matter of choice.
Although we live in modern, democratic Christian country, enjoying tremendous personal freedom, perhaps OAC may be one step too far. It would be impossible to find suitable places in our overcrowded cities, even more difficult to get planning permission. It has to be in countryside, far away from human habitation which will create transport difficulties.
Some among indigenous population may find it objectionable, even barbaric. Moreover it requires dedicated team to plan, perform and manage the site. There were seasoned volunteers in Africa who undertook these heart-breaking thankless tasks. It is too gruesome to contemplate what happens while body is on funeral-pyre, definitely out of bound for ladies and children. Hinduism is progressive religion, moves with time. Even Indian cities are adopting new technology.
Being only male relative in India in 1950s, I was obliged to light funeral fire when my grandfather passed away. It was time in hell, suffering from nightmares for months. Perhaps readers may like to share their experiences with us!
Bhupendra M. Gandhi
By email
